Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer

The Class Nature Under the Colonial System: A Critical Study of Old Shanghai as a Case

Abstract

In globalization, imperialism persists through more concealed forms of domination. Colonial history has not ended; it has been reconfigured within global political economy and cultural consciousness. This paper argues that the racial and national contradictions visible in colonial and semi-colonial settings such as old Shanghai were, at root, expressions of the global expansion of monopoly capital and class rule. Combining postcolonial critique with Marxist political economy, and drawing on Lenin’s theory of imperialism, the study analyzes old Shanghai through three dimensions: legal-spatial institutions, internal divisions within foreign and Chinese societies, and the cultural field. It shows that racial contradictions functioned less as fundamental causes than as surface forms and strategic instruments that concealed deeper class antagonisms. Reconsidering China’s anti-imperialist struggle from a class perspective, the paper stresses the historical unity of national liberation and working-class emancipation. Old Shanghai thus provides a historical lens for understanding the enduring entanglement of capital, cultural hegemony, and class struggle in both past and present global orders.

全球化时代,帝国主义以更隐蔽的方式延续支配逻辑。殖民历史并未终结,而是被重新嵌入全球政治经济结构与文化意识。本文认为,旧上海等殖民与半殖民场域中的种族与民族矛盾,本质上是国际垄断资本扩张和阶级统治的表现。本文结合后殖民理论与马克思主义政治经济学,并以列宁帝国主义理论为基础,从法律—空间制度、侨民社会与华人社会内部裂隙、文化场域三个维度分析旧上海。研究表明,种族矛盾并非根本原因,而更多是遮蔽深层阶级对立的表层现象和策略工具。通过以阶级视角重审中国反帝斗争,本文强调民族解放与劳动阶级解放的历史统一。旧上海因此成为理解资本逻辑、文化霸权与阶级斗争在历史与当代全球秩序中持续交织的重要棱镜。

Keywords

colonial system, class contradiction, old Shanghai, Lenin’s theory of imperialism, postcolonialism, Marxism, cultural hegemony, Sino-foreign relations, semi-colonialism, emancipatory politics

PDF

References

  1. Ahmad, Aijaz. 1992. In Theory: Classes, Nations, Literatures. London: Verso.
  2. Bhabha, Homi K. 1994. The Location of Culture. London: Routledge.
  3. Chakrabarty, Dipesh. 2000. Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical Difference. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
  4. Dirlik, Arif. 1997. The Postcolonial Aura: Third World Criticism in the Age of Global Capitalism. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
  5. Gramsci, Antonio. 1971. Selections from the Prison Notebooks. Translated by Quintin Hoare and Geoffrey Nowell Smith. New York: International Publishers.
  6. Lee, Leo Ou-fan. 1999. Shanghai Modern: The Printing and Urban Culture in the Early Twentieth Century. Berkeley: University of California Press.
  7. Lenin, V. I. 1917. Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism. In Collected Works, vol. 22. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
  8. Marx, Karl. 1853. “The British Rule in India.” New York Daily Tribune, June 25.
  9. Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o. 1986. Decolonising the Mind: The Politics of Language in African Literature. London: James Currey.
  10. Said, Edward W. 1978. Orientalism. New York: Pantheon Books.
  11. Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty. 1988. “Can the Subaltern Speak?” In Marxism and the Interpretation of Culture, edited by Cary Nelson and Lawrence Grossberg, 271–313. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
  12. Altan, Selda. 2020. “Chinese Labor on the Yunnan-Vietnam Railway: Race, Class, and Everyday Resistance in French Colonial Projects.” Journal of Asian Studies 79 (3): 567–589.
  13. Xiong, Yuezhi. 1999. Shanghai Tongshi [A Comprehensive History of Shanghai], 15 vols. Shanghai: Shanghai Renmin Chubanshe. (Xiong Yuezhi’s analysis of the “one city, three administrations” pattern appears in his related works.)
  14. Zhang, Peng. 2008. Dushi xingtai de lishi genji: Shanghai gonggong zujie shizheng fazhan yu dushi bianqian yanjiu [The Historical Foundations of Urban Form: A Study of Municipal Development and Urban Transformation in the Shanghai International Settlement]. Shanghai: Tongji University Press.
  15. Lian, Lingling. 2017. Dazao xiaofei tiantang: baigongsi yu jindai Shanghai chengshi wenhua [Creating a Consumer Paradise: Department Stores and Modern Urban Culture in Shanghai]. Taipei: Institute of Modern History, Academia Sinica.
  16. Lee, Leo Ou-fan. 2001. Shanghai Modern: The Flowering of a New Urban Culture in China, 1930–1945. Translated by Mao Jian. Beijing: Peking University Press; revised edition, Shanghai: Shanghai Joint Publishing, 2008.
  17. Chen, Yunqian. 2009. Chongbai yu jiyi: Sun Zhongshan fuhao de jiangou yu chuanbo [Worship and Memory: The Construction and Dissemination of Sun Yat-sen Symbols]. Nanjing: Nanjing University Press. (Includes chapters on modern parks and colonialism.)
  18. Zheng, Shiling. 2002. Shanghai jianzhu fengge yu chengshi wenhua [Shanghai Architectural Styles and Urban Culture]. Shanghai: Shanghai Education Publishing House. (Analysis of the Bund architectural ensemble.)
  19. Wang, Zhicheng. 1993. Shanghai E’qiao shi [History of Russian Émigrés in Shanghai]. Shanghai: Shanghai Joint Publishing.
  20. Hao, Yen-p’ing. 1988. The Comprador in Nineteenth-Century China: Bridge between East and West. Translated by Li Rongchang et al. Shanghai: Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences Press.
  21. Perry, Elizabeth J. 2001. Shanghai Strikes: A Study of Chinese Worker Politics. Translated by Liu Ping. Nanjing: Jiangsu People’s Publishing House.
  22. Ye, Wenxin. 2010. Shanghai Splendor: Economic Ethics and Modern China. Taipei: Commonwealth Publishing Group.
  23. Xiong, Yuezhi. 2021. “Shanghai chengshi de guojixing yu Zhonggong de chuangli ji zaoqi fazhan” [The International Character of Shanghai and the Founding and Early Development of the Chinese Communist Party]. Shijie lishi, no. 2.
  24. Xiong, Yuezhi. 2013. “Jindai Shanghai gongyuan yu shehui shenghuo” [Modern Shanghai Parks and Social Life]. Shehui kexue, no. 5.
  25. Chen, Yunqian. 2005. “Richang shenghuo zhong zhiminzhuyi yu minzuzhuyi de chongtu: yi Zhongguo jindai gongyuan wei zhongxin de kaocha” [Colonialism and Nationalism in Everyday Life: An Examination Centered on Modern Chinese Parks]. Jiangsu shehui kexue, no. 3.
  26. Ma, Changlin. 2008. “Shanghai zujie xingzheng guanli fagui de fazhan yu yanbian” [The Development and Evolution of Administrative Regulations in the Shanghai Concessions]. Research report, Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences.
  27. Ma, Changlin. 1990. “Shanghai gonggong zujie gongbuju yanjiu” [A Study of the Shanghai Municipal Council]. Jindai shi yanjiu, no. 3.
  28. Ma, Changlin. 2014. “Fa zujie yu jindai Shanghai” [The French Concession and Modern Shanghai]. Paper presented at the International Academic Symposium on the French Concession and Modern Shanghai, Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences Institute of History and Lyon East Asia Institute, Shanghai, May.
  29. Ye, Bin. n.d. “Huishen gongxie yu jindai Shanghai zujie de sifa zhili” [The Mixed Court and Judicial Governance in Modern Shanghai Concessions]. Unpublished paper, Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences Institute of History.
  30. Li, Haoxian. 2007. “Shanghai huishen gongxie yu Zhongxi falü jiaoshe” [The Shanghai Mixed Court and Sino-Western Legal Interactions]. PhD diss., Fudan University.
  31. Wang, Jian. 2014. “Fa zujie yu Shanghai chengshi bianqian” [The French Concession and Urban Transformation in Shanghai]. Shilin, no. 4.
  32. Li, Aili. 2007. “Yihe yanghang yu jindai Shanghai Ying shang shehui” [Jardine Matheson and the British Merchant Community in Modern Shanghai]. PhD diss., Fudan University.
  33. Wu, Yongmei. 2012. “Jindai Shanghai zujie de Nanya xunbu yanjiu” [A Study of South Asian Constables in Modern Shanghai Concessions]. Yazhou yanjiu, no. 2.
  34. Zhang, Jishun. 1998. “Shanghai zujie yu jindai Zhongguo minzuzhuyi” [The Shanghai Concessions and Modern Chinese Nationalism]. Lishi yanjiu, no. 2.
  35. Xu, Jilin. 2004. “Dushi kongjian shiye zhong de zhishi fenzi yanjiu” [Intellectual Studies from the Perspective of Urban Space]. Tianjin shehui kexue, no. 3.
  36. Chen, Jianhua. 2007. “‘Geming’ yu ‘xiandai’ de jiaocha: lun 1920 niandai Shanghai zuoyi wenyi yundong” [The Intersection of “Revolution” and “Modernity”: On the Left-Wing Literary Movement in 1920s Shanghai]. Zhongguo xiandai wenxue yanjiu congkan, no. 1.
  37. Ni, Wei. 2008. “Zuoyi wenhua yundong yu Shanghai chengshi kongjian” [The Left-Wing Cultural Movement and Urban Space in Shanghai]. Wenyi yanjiu, no. 3.
  38. Zhou, Wu. 2014. “Shanghai Fa zujie shi yanjiu de ruogan wenti” [Several Issues in the Study of the History of the Shanghai French Concession]. In Fa zujie yu jindai Shanghai [The French Concession and Modern Shanghai], proceedings of the international symposium.
  39. Mou, Zhenyu. 2014. “Kaibu chuqi Shanghai Fa qiao renkou, zhiye ji shehui wangluo (1842–1875)” [French Expatriate Population, Occupations, and Social Networks in Early Treaty-Port Shanghai, 1842–1875]. In Fa zujie yu jindai Shanghai [The French Concession and Modern Shanghai], proceedings of the international symposium.
  40. Hou, Qingbin. 2014. “Wenti, shiliao yu fangfa: Shanghai Fa zujie huishen gongxie (1869–1931) yanjiu de ruogan sikao” [Issues, Sources, and Methods: Reflections on the Study of the Shanghai French Concession Mixed Court, 1869–1931]. In Fa zujie yu jindai Shanghai [The French Concession and Modern Shanghai], proceedings of the international symposium.
  41. Cornet, Christine. 2014. “Fuwu yu Shanghai Fa zujie de Yuenan jingcha (1906–1946): bei fu, anju, baojian yu jiaoyu” [Serving in the Shanghai French Concession: Vietnamese Police, 1906–1946—Uniforms, Housing, Health, and Education]. In Fa zujie yu jindai Shanghai [The French Concession and Modern Shanghai], proceedings of the international symposium.
  42. Zhu, Xiaoming. n.d. “Shanghai Fa zujie Yuenan xunbu yanjiu” [A Study of Vietnamese Constables in the Shanghai French Concession]. Unpublished paper, School of International Studies, Renmin University of China.
  43. Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party. 1922. “Manifesto of the Second National Congress of the CCP.” In Selected Documents of the CCP Central Committee, vol. 1. Beijing: Foreign Languages Press (reprinted edition).
  44. Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party. 1931. “Guanyu fan di douzheng zhong women gongzuo de cuowu yu quedian de jueyi” [Resolution on Errors and Shortcomings in Our Work in the Anti-Imperialist Struggle]. In Selected Documents of the CCP Central Committee.